Skip to main content

Chautauqua County Supreme Court

A reference guide for filing civil lawsuits and personal injury cases at Chautauqua County Supreme Court in Mayville, New York.

This guide is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws may have changed since publication. Consult a licensed New York attorney for advice specific to your situation.
Mayville, Chautauqua County Updated March 2026

About Chautauqua County Supreme Court

Chautauqua County Supreme Court is the primary civil trial court for Chautauqua County, handling major lawsuits, serious personal injury cases, and civil matters that exceed the jurisdiction of local city and town courts.

Most serious personal injury cases in Jamestown and Chautauqua County — including car accidents, slip and fall injuries, dog bites, and pedestrian accidents — are filed here when damages exceed $15,000.

Cases at this level involve more formal procedures than city court. Jury trials are available, and attorneys are strongly recommended for Supreme Court civil actions.

Court Location

  • Address: 1 N Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757
  • Hours: Monday–Friday, 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Phone: (716) 753-4266
  • Website: nycourts.gov

Types of Cases Handled

Chautauqua County Supreme Court handles civil matters of all sizes, with no upper dollar limit on claims.

Car Accident Lawsuits

Personal injury claims arising from traffic crashes in Chautauqua County where damages exceed $15,000.

Slip and Fall Injuries

Premises liability cases involving injuries on commercial, residential, or public property.

Dog Bite and Animal Attack Claims

Personal injury cases under New York Agriculture & Markets Law § 123.

Pedestrian and Bicycle Accidents

Claims involving pedestrians or cyclists struck by motor vehicles.

Appeals from Lower Courts

Civil decisions from Jamestown City Court and other local courts that are appealed to Supreme Court.

Filing a Civil Case Here

Before You File

  • 1 Confirm your claim exceeds Jamestown City Court's $15,000 civil limit
  • 2 Purchase an index number from the Chautauqua County Clerk's office
  • 3 Prepare your summons and complaint describing the facts, defendant, and damages
  • 4 Confirm you are within the 3-year statute of limitations ( CPLR § 214 )
  • 5 If a government entity is involved, confirm a Notice of Claim was filed within 90 days

At Your Hearing

  • 1 Arrive early — security screening is required at entry
  • 2 Bring all documentation, medical records, photos, and evidence
  • 3 Address the judge as "Your Honor"
  • 4 Follow your attorney's guidance throughout proceedings
  • 5 Most personal injury cases settle before trial — be prepared for both outcomes

Getting to Chautauqua County Supreme Court

The courthouse is located at 1 N Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757 — approximately 18 miles north of Jamestown, about 25 minutes via NY-394 W. Parking is available near the courthouse in Mayville. Arrive early as security screening is required for all court appearances.

Official Sources

Back to top